April 23, 2021

Man Utd

News

Manchester City vs Man United: How Maguire and Lindelof’s lack of authority has cost United

7 min read

Not so long ago, you would have been forgiven for thinking today’s Manchester derby could go some way to deciding whether the title would end up in the blue or red half of the city.

But when talk of a title bid really hit home for United, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s side started to stumble and have not quite managed to get back up on their feet, while City have not looked back.

Pep Guardiola‘s side are looking to break even more records amid their ridiculous 21-match winning streak in all competitions, and the finishing line is firmly in their sights.

Ruben Dias and John Stones have laid the foundations for champions-elect Manchester City

Ruben Dias and John Stones have laid the foundations for champions-elect Manchester City

Man United duo Harry Maguire and Victor Lindelof have struggled to dominate rival attacks

Man United duo Harry Maguire and Victor Lindelof have struggled to dominate rival attacks

Following yet another setback for United on Thursday at Crystal Palace, City find themselves a massive 14 points clear with just 11 matches remaining, and are on course to capture their third Premier League crown in four years.

But while their free-flowing attacking football is winning plenty of plaudits, and rightly so, their renewed defensive fortitude has been just as integral.  

And they have £64million signing Ruben Dias and his centre-back partner John Stones, who has enjoyed an incredible renaissance, to thank.

DIAS/STONES VS MAGUIRE/LINDELOF IN PL 2020-21 (STATS VIA OPTA) 
PL 2020-21 Ruben Dias/John Stones Harry Maguire/Victor Lindelof
Games 14 20
Wins 13 10
Draws 1 8
Losses 0 2
Goals against 3 22
Avg. goals against 0.2 1.1
Clean sheets 11 7
Win per cent 92.9 50
Points/Game 2.9 1.9
Shots conceded/game 7.1 11.1
Fouls conceded/game 8 11.8

The pair, who both scored in last weekend’s 2-1 win at home to West Ham, have provided the backbone for City’s march to the title but across the city, United’s defensive fortunes are very different. 

Yes, goals have dried up in recent matches, but throughout the season both Harry Maguire and Victor Lindelof as a pair have not convinced, and the side have dropped far too many points due to a lack of authority at the back. 

United legend and former right back Gary Neville has previously admitted his concerns over the central defensive partnership, insisting they cannot play together. 

After a costly slip-up at relegation threatened West Brom last month, Neville said: ‘Lindelof’s problem is Maguire, Maguire’s problem is Lindelof.

‘I think he (Lindelof) is a really good player by the way, he understands the game, he reads the game, I think he is a good defender. I think if he was alongside a (Rio) Ferdinand or Van Dijk, I think he would make a great pair.

‘The problem is he is alongside somebody who isn’t the most mobile in Harry Maguire, and I think that is the problem that Lindelof has got. That actually they have invested £80m in Maguire, so they are going to have to put somebody beside him.  

‘I don’t think he does a good job alongside Maguire because they both just drop back a little bit and United need someone to get up the pitch. They have got to get up the pitch, they have got to be more aggressive.

‘They have got to have the nerve to make the stomach churn a little bit, that there is a bit too much space in behind them than there ordinarily would be and that is what the best teams have.’

Dias and Stones have conceded just three times in 14 Premier League matches together

Dias and Stones have conceded just three times in 14 Premier League matches together

United have dropped points this season due to lapses in concentration in defence

United have dropped points this season due to lapses in concentration in defence 

LEAST GOALS CONCEDED IN PL 
Team Goals conceded Clean sheets
Man City 17 15
Chelsea 25 12
Aston Villa 27 13
Arsenal 27 8
Tottenham 27 8
West Ham 31 9
Leicester 31 9
Man United 32 10
Fulham 32 8
Brighton 33 8
Everton 33 6
Liverpool 34 7
Burnley 35 9
Wolves 37 7
Crystal Palace 43 6
Sheffield United 43 2
Southampton 44 8
Leeds 44 8
Newcastle 44 4
West Brom 55 4

It’s a far cry from the glory days when Rio Ferdinand teamed up alongside Nemanja Vidic in the heart of the defence, or going even further back when Steve Bruce played next to Gary Pallister.

And when you compare United’s centre back duo to Sunday’s counterparts the difference is there for all to see.

City are miles ahead of every other team defensively this season, it must be said, but you don’t win titles without a formidable spine at the back.

Since Dias and Stones partnered each other for the first time this season, City have won 13 and drawn one of their 14 matches.

They have incredibly conceded just three times in that spell at a rate of only 0.2 goals per match. 

The unlikely coming together has clearly helped reinvigorate City. Guardiola’s side, with an array of talent at their disposal with Ilkay Gundogan, Raheem Sterling, Kevin De Bruyne and Riyad Mahrez all shining this term just to name a few, have full trust in their defensive duo that they can purely focus on the attacking aspect of things.

But this isn’t the case for United, who flatter to deceive with Maguire and Lindelof at the back. In their 20 Premier League matches together this term, United have won just 10 times and their eight draws stand out with a points average of 1.9.

The Red Devils have conceded 22 times with Lindelof and Maguire in central defence – shipping in goals at an average of 1.1 times per match.

Pep Guardiola is on the brink of landing a third Premier League title in four campaigns

Pep Guardiola is on the brink of landing a third Premier League title in four campaigns

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer's United side have faltered in recent weeks and are 14 points behind City

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s United side have faltered in recent weeks and are 14 points behind City

Mistakes continue to creep into their game, and opposition teams are there to punish them when they switch off. And that was evident against both Everton and West Brom recently.

Against Everton, after edging 3-2 in front after initially letting a two-goal lead slip, they had just seconds to see out the victory at Old Trafford. But from a Toffees free-kick in injury-time, United deployed a deep backline in their own box (echoing Neville’s comments), before playing Dominic Calvert-Lewin onside, who had the easy task of tapping home.

And away at West Brom, Lindelof was far too easily out-muscled as Mbaye Diagne headed the hosts in front at the Hawthorns. The pair are vulnerable and opponents know they can be got at.

The United duo are also conceding 11.1 shots each fixture, which is four more exactly compared to Dias and Stones. 

If the Old Trafford outfit have hopes of winning the title anytime soon, regardless of how good their attack is, it is very unlikely they would do so with Maguire teaming up with Lindelof.

City are putting their defensive counterparts to shame, but while we can continue to talk about United, Guardiola’s backline are in fact embarrassing everyone this term. 

FEWEST GOALS CONCEDED IN A PREMIER LEAGUE SEASON
Team Season Goals conceded Clean sheets
Chelsea 2004-05 15 25
Arsenal 1998-99 17 23
Man City* 2020-21 17 15
Man United 2007-08 22 21
Liverpool 2018-19 22 21
Chelsea 2005-06 22 20
Man City 2018-19 23 20
Man United 2008-09 24 24
Chelsea 2008-09 24 22
Chelsea 2006-07 24 22
Liverpool 2005-06 25 22

City stars Stones (94%), Oleksandr Zinchenko (92%), Joao Cancelo (76%), Dias (75%) and Aymeric Laporte (70%) have the best win rate among Premier League defenders to have played 10 or more games this term.

And throughout the 2020-21 campaign so far, City have conceded just 17 times in 27 matches. Chelsea boast the second best defensive record but that is still eight goals worse off while Arsenal, Tottenham and Aston Villa are two further back.

In fact, if City keep up their emphatic resilience, they will take their place among the most successful defences in Premier League history.

City currently sit joint-second with Arsenal (1998-99) in terms of least goals conceded in a Premier League season, with only Chelsea’s 2004-05 title winning team letting in less with 15 overall.

Yes there is still 11 matches to go for City, but if they can somehow only concede four goals or fewer until the end of the season, they will stake their claim as the joint-second best defensive side in the Premier League era.

Following a slow start to the season, which saw the club fall eight points off top spot in November after losing 2-0 at Tottenham, City have not looked back and have demolished everyone in their wake.

In years gone by, it has largely been City’s front line that has powered them to the title, and while their attacking talents are delivering once again this season, Dias and Stones will be widely recognised for laying the foundations.

The City juggernaut is showing no signs of slowing down and come Sunday afternoon, it would be hard to look past another Guardiola victory.

BEST WIN RATE AMONG PL DEFENDERS THIS SEASON WITH 10+ APPS
Defender Team Apps Wins W%
John Stones Man City 16 15 94
Oleksandr Zinchenko Man City 12 11 92
Joao Cancelo Man City 21 16 76
Ruben Dias Man City 24 18 75
Aymeric Laporte Man City 10 7 70
Craig Dawson West Ham 11 7 64
Kyle Walker Man City 18 11 61
Matt Doherty Tottenham 12 7 58
Yerry Mina Everton 19 11 58
Caglar Soyuncu Leicester 14 8 57
James Justin Leicester 23 13 57
MINUTES PER GOAL CONCEDED RATE AMONG DEFENDERS IN PL
Defender Team Minutes Goals conceded Mins/goal conceded Clean sheets
John Stones Man City 1440 4 360 12
Kortney Hause Aston Villa 360 1 360 3
Oleksandr Zinchenko Man City 910 3 303.3 6
Joao Cancelo Man City 1793 9 199.2 11
Antonio Rudiger Chelsea 990 5 198 7
Ruben Dias Man City 2140 11 194.5 13
Pablo Mari Arsenal 450 3 150 2
Cesar Azpilicueta Chelsea 1310 9 145.6 9
Ahmed El Mohamady Aston Villa 428 3 142.7 2
Aymeric Laporte Man City 848 6 141.3 4
Copyright © All rights reserved. | Newsphere by AF themes.